Gavan Reilly's Portfolio writings, ramblings, mumblings

Published on
10 November, 2009

Published in
The University Observer

Comments Off on Former UCDSU President nominated for Seanad seat

Former UCDSU President nominated for Seanad seat

Former President of UCD Students’ Union, James Carroll, has been nominated by Fianna Fáil to contest a by-election to Seanad Éireann.

jamesCarroll, 26, was elected to Louth County Council this Summer, elected on the first count to the Drogheda East electoral area.

Carroll served as President of UCD Students’ Union in 2005-06, after previously serving as Education Officer of the Union.

The seat in the Seanad has arisen on the Administrative Panel, following the death earlier this year of Senator Tony Kett. Unlike Seanad general elections, where members of all of Ireland’s local town and county councils can vote, voting in Seanad by-elections is only extended to members of the Dáil, meaning that Carroll’s appointment is all but guaranteed.

Carroll graduated from UCD with a Bachelors degree in Civil Law in 2007, and currently works as a parliamentary assistant to Margaret Conlon, Fianna Fáil TD for Cavan-Monaghan.

More on this story as it comes in.

Link: James Carroll’s websiteTwitter


Published on
10 November, 2009

Published in
The University Observer

Comments Off on A ballot box of red tape

A ballot box of red tape

Important as the appointment of the EU’s first full-time President might be, Gavan Reilly believes picking a new Commissioner will be a more pressing concern [Read more →]


Published on
10 November, 2009

Published in
The University Observer

Comments Off on Webwatch

Webwatch

with Gavan Reilly [Read more →]


Published on
31 October, 2009

Published in
Back Page Football

Comments Off on Bottoms Up: Can the Carling Cup survive?

Bottoms Up: Can the Carling Cup survive?

Gav Reilly argues for reform of the League Cup before it becomes an unworkable, worthless shambles – but what do you think?

The draw for the quarter-finals of the Carling Cup was released this morning; the world kept turning.

A quick history lesson: the League Cup was instituted in 1960-61 as a tournament specifically created to abuse the newly-installed floodlights in the grounds of league clubs up and down the country. (While the bigger clubs – most notably Manchester United – had had lights installed in the mid-1950s, so as to take part in European midweek competition, other clubs followed suit at the turn of the decade.) The notion was to hold a mid-week only tournament, abusing the newfound ability of clubs to host games during the darker winter evenings.

Bigger clubs weren’t having it. European competition was still a runner for most of them and it was only when the prize of a UEFA Cup spot was thrown in for the winners that big clubs wanted to do it. Even from the off, the bigger teams needed a bribe to get in.

While it’s easy to say that the Carling Cup has gotten predictable – the Uniteds and Arsenals of the world will put out their young lads until they make the last four, while the absence of any real romance to the competition will stop smaller teams from genuinely believing – and moreover, carrying out – any major acts of giant-killing. This year the quarter-finalists are all from the Premiership – including three of the Big Four as well as this year’s new league upstarts from Man City and Tottenham – crucifying the notion that the competition still offers any chance for a smaller time to reach the big time, get a day out, and find a spot in Europe.

man-utd-carling-cup-2009It’s not as if offering a spot in Europe is a particular pre-requisite that the Football League need to work out of their systems. Only England and France offer a European spot to the winners of their secondary cup competitions; the Copa del Rey or the Ligapokal don’t offer their winners anything other than a pot of silverware. In essence, being consistently dominated by teams who already have their European entry guaranteed by league performance, the League Cup has become this.

But, instead of abandoning the tournament (an idea that would have much support), the Carling Cup would be of far better use if it was to be another chance for smaller, non-European-bound teams to have their chance.

So here’s an idea. There are only 92 teams in the tournament in the first place, with a skewed system seeding teams in European competition in further rounds. How about excluding teams already taking part in European competition that year? What good is the tournament if it becomes another chance for Arsene Wenger or Rafa Benitez to win a trophy and keep people off their backs, when a slightly smaller club (even a mid-table Premiership outfit like West Ham) could benefit so much more?

This isn’t so much an opinion piece as an open call for a debate on how to make the competition work. Is there a future for the League Cup? Is it perfect as it is, or how could it be made better?


Published on
27 October, 2009

Published in
The University Observer

Comments Off on SU and UCD to agree Student Centre refund

SU and UCD to agree Student Centre refund

The University Observer understands that UCD Students’ Union and the University are on the verge of agreeing an unprecedented deal that will see UCD refund €7.50 of the Student Centre Levy paid by all students this year. [Read more →]


Published on
27 October, 2009

Published in
The University Observer

Comments Off on The Upper House rules

The Upper House rules

Enda Kenny’s proposal to abolish the Seanad is a foolish, short-term solution to a long-term problem, writes Gavan Reilly [Read more →]


Published on
27 October, 2009

Published in
The University Observer

Comments Off on Challenging Times

Challenging Times

As Students’ Union activists occupy the offices of Wicklow County Council, Gavan Reilly ponders the merits of public demonstrations [Read more →]


Published on
27 October, 2009

Published in
The University Observer

Comments Off on Webwatch: October 27th, 2009

Published on
27 October, 2009

Published in
The University Observer

Comments Off on French teaching attacked in quality review

French teaching attacked in quality review

A new quality review report has heavily criticised the staffing and administrative structures governing the teaching of French in UCD’s School of Languages and Literatures. [Read more →]


Published on
16 October, 2009

Published in
Back Page Football

Comments Off on Opinion: the Italian Blob

Opinion: the Italian Blob

Returning from a professional sabbatical and into actual sunlight for the first time in what feels like several years, Gav Reilly thinks that Football might finally, in 2010, come home…

First of all, apologies for my radio silence of late; I’ve been wrapped up in a windowless office of doom for the past couple of months working on my college newspaper and trust me when I say that I see so little sunlight these days that rickets is a genuine possibility. (OK, slight exaggeration, but you get the idea.)

Working in an enclosed environment with no TVs and countless computer monitors gives a football fan an odd experience. While I can’t remember the last time I watched a Super Sunday, I end up putting on a lot of fringe football matches on a spare computer monitor to help pass the time. Perhaps these circumstances are totally screwing with my head, but I have come to some rather startling conclusions during my relative alone time.

I think England are going to win the 2010 World Cup.

Let me explain, in a typically circuitous way. International football is a strange beast; it’s difficult to get into the habit of following an international team with any sense of religiousness when, aside from a month every two years (at best), the sides are fleeting compilations of form players, who put one or two matches together and then dissolve back into the club scene. Following an international team who enjoy a reasonable degree of success is a bit like being a diehard follower of the Harlem Globetrotters: you watch a match, expecting a win; you get it, and you leave chirped, but without proceedings having any major impact on your being.

Following England must, for the natives, have become quite similar in the past months. Since the appointment of Fabio Capello, while the side have never been breathlessly stunning, they have still managed to be potent up front with relative ease, stable at the back, and generally solid. They’re like Ireland on steroids: it’s a carbon copy of Giovanni Trapattoni’s uninspiring but effective side, but with some decent firepower (it helps when your best striker isn’t a heart-on-sleeve captain who can’t help but fall back to try and exert some influence, only to leave a Robbie Keane-shaped hole in attack as soon as the ball gets up there) and a sturdy, Top 4 defence.

England, for all their public’s bemoaning and the general tedium they inspire on the field, have been in quite phenomenal form in qualifying for 2010, winning 9 games of 10, scoring more goals than any other side in Europe (and possibly the world) along the way and only losing one game when qualification was long since secured.

There are no major flaws with the side; they’re defensively as resolute as they come, their midfielders are the best in the world, and up front they have plenty of choices, all of whom can put them away when needed – as evidenced in the qualifiers. Get a goalkeeper and they’re sorted: and give Paul Robinson enough chances and he’ll end up taking them with both hands. The English squad, bar the netminders, have all won the club game’s top prizes: it’s just now up to someone to knit them all together.

Oddly, it seems that England’s steadfast consistency in the qualifying games has done just that. Instead of the schizophrenic form that characterised the Englands of old – exactly the form that turned the media on them, when their poor form underlined their inadequacies that their successes proved could be circumvented – the modern, Capello-led England have, like Ireland, become a side that plays in the Italian way. Boring, but effective. Not phenomenal in front of goal, but they can get the goals they need, when they need to.

An efficient side, that might not be amazing, but can do what they need, when they need. Remind you of anyone?


← Before After →